Do cars come with both Apple CarPlay and Android Auto?
Apple CarPlay and Android Auto are two of the most popular in-car infotainment platforms that allow drivers to access smartphone apps and functions through the vehicle’s infotainment system display. CarPlay, launched in 2014, enables iPhone users to make calls, send messages, listen to music, get directions, and more from the dashboard. Android Auto, which debuted in 2015, offers similar functionality for Android users.
With consumer demand for connected vehicles continuing to rise, compatibility with both CarPlay and Android Auto has become an important consideration for many car buyers. According to a 2022 survey, over 50% of consumers said integration of their smartphone apps was a top priority when choosing a new vehicle. As a result, support for both platforms is seen as a way for automakers to satisfy customers and stay competitive in the market.
What is Apple CarPlay?
Apple CarPlay is an in-vehicle platform developed by Apple that allows iPhone users to integrate their phone with their vehicle’s infotainment system. It was first announced in 2014 and is now available from most major auto manufacturers.
CarPlay effectively mirrors certain apps and features from an iPhone onto the vehicle’s built-in display, allowing the driver to access key functionality through the dashboard rather than picking up their phone. This helps minimize distractions while driving.
Some of the key features accessible through CarPlay include:
- Maps and navigation through Apple Maps
- Phone functions like making/receiving calls and accessing voicemail
- Messaging via iMessage or third-party apps like WhatsApp
- Media playback from iTunes library or compatible apps
- Personal assistant through Siri
- Select third-party audio, messaging, and voice apps
By connecting an iPhone to a CarPlay compatible vehicle, users can utilize these features and apps through the vehicle’s touchscreen, knobs, steering wheel controls etc. This allows drivers to minimize interaction with their phones and focus on the road.
What is Android Auto?
Android Auto is a platform developed by Google that allows Android smartphones to integrate with a vehicle’s infotainment system. It was first announced in 2014 and allows drivers to access apps and services from their phone in a safer, more convenient way while driving.
The main functionality of Android Auto is providing a simplified interface projected onto the vehicle’s center screen, optimized for use while driving. This allows drivers to access key apps and services like navigation, music, messaging, and voice assistants more easily. Touch inputs are limited to reduce driver distraction.
Some of the key features of Android Auto include voice commands, Google Maps navigation, media playback, hands-free calling and text messaging, weather information, and integration with the Google Assistant. It aims to minimize interactions with the touchscreen and reduce distraction.
By connecting an Android phone to a compatible car, drivers can leverage the apps and services they’re already familiar with on their smartphone while driving. This allows for a more seamless, intuitive in-car experience.
Manufacturer Implementations
Most automakers offer both CarPlay and Android Auto in their newest vehicles. According to Cars.com, manufacturers like Acura, Audi, BMW, Ford, Honda, Hyundai, Kia, Mercedes-Benz, Nissan, Subaru, Toyota, and Volkswagen all support both systems in select models (Cars.com). This allows the in-vehicle infotainment system to connect seamlessly with either iOS or Android smartphones.
However, some automakers only offer one or the other. For example, Polestar vehicles currently only support Android Auto, while Lucid Motors vehicles currently only support CarPlay. Tesla is a notable exception, as they have proprietary software and do not allow either CarPlay or Android Auto integration (The Verge).
Supporting both systems requires extra development time and cost for automakers, but provides maximum compatibility for consumers. As mobile OS preference continues to be split between Android and iOS, most major manufacturers have chosen to enable connectivity with both platforms.
Benefits of Supporting Both CarPlay and Android Auto
Offering both Apple CarPlay and Android Auto in vehicles provides several key benefits for automakers:
Increased consumer choice and compatibility: By supporting both platforms, automakers allow consumers to easily connect and integrate their preferred smartphone platform into the vehicle. This provides a seamless, familiar experience for iPhone and Android users alike (Your New Vehicle Should Have Apple CarPlay Or Android Auto – Forbes Wheels).
Meeting consumer demand: Surveys show the vast majority of new car buyers want Apple CarPlay and Android Auto compatibility. By providing both options, automakers can satisfy consumer demand and expectations for smartphone integration (The rest of the auto industry still loves CarPlay and Android Auto – The Verge).
Competitive advantage: In a crowded market, offering popular features like CarPlay and Android Auto can give automakers an edge over competitors. Vehicles lacking smartphone integration may be seen as outdated or behind-the-times by many shoppers.
Challenges of Supporting Both
Automakers face significant challenges in trying to integrate both Apple CarPlay and Android Auto into their infotainment systems. One major challenge is the increased development costs involved. Car manufacturers have to devote more engineering resources to ensure both platforms work smoothly in their vehicles. According to an article on Ars Technica, “CarPlay and Android Auto have stability issues that manifest as bad connections, poor rendering, slow responses, and dropped commands” (1). Fixing these technical issues requires ongoing investments.
There’s also the challenge of fragmented implementation. Even though Apple and Google provide guidelines, how each automaker integrates CarPlay and Android Auto varies. This can create a disjointed and inconsistent experience. As Motor Trend notes, “The look, feel, functionality, and feature set differ from automaker to automaker” (2). Trying to optimize the user interface and experience across both platforms can lead to compromises.
These compromises often impact the UI/UX design. Automakers may be forced to adopt more generic designs that don’t fully leverage the capabilities of each platform. Certain features may only be available on one system. This can frustrate users who expect a uniform experience. There are no easy solutions, and supporting both CarPlay and Android Auto involves ongoing trade-offs.
(1) https://arstechnica.com/cars/2023/12/gm-justifies-decision-to-ditch-apple-carplay-due-to-stability-issues/
(2) https://www.motortrend.com/news/general-motors-removing-apple-carplay-android-auto-for-safety-tim-babbitt/
The Consumer Perspective
Consumers increasingly prefer vehicles that offer cross-platform compatibility with both major smartphone operating systems, Apple iOS and Android. According to a recent McKinsey survey, 45 percent of car owners who have Apple CarPlay or Android Auto use the service regularly, with another 40 percent connecting periodically.
This desire for seamless integration with their chosen smartphone ecosystem means consumers want the ability to safely access their apps, contacts, music and more while driving. However, many drivers express frustration when their vehicle only supports one platform over the other, or lacks compatibility entirely.
With CarPlay and Auto rapidly becoming must-have features, limited OEM support remains an issue. Per McKinsey, nearly 50% of car buyers will not consider a vehicle lacking compatibility with their operating system of choice. This reluctance presents a challenge for manufacturers, as consumers clearly favor cross-platform interoperability.
The Future Outlook
The future looks bright for both CarPlay and Android Auto. According to McKinsey, the connected car services market is projected to grow at a CAGR of 20% from 2020-2030, reaching a value of $225 billion by 2030 [1]. As leading providers of in-car infotainment systems, CarPlay and Android Auto are poised to capture much of this growth.
Increased cross-compatibility between the two platforms also seems likely. While currently limited, some automakers like Honda allow both CarPlay and Android Auto to work simultaneously in select models [2]. As the connected car market grows, consumer demand for flexibility and choice will push more automakers to support concurrent connectivity. This benefits consumers by providing seamless accessibility and switching between iOS and Android devices.
New competitors like Amazon’s Alexa Auto may gain some market share, but are unlikely to unseat the dominance of CarPlay and Android Auto in the near future. The data shows consumers overwhelmingly prefer the tight integration, usability, and ecosystem benefits the two leading platforms provide thanks to their software and hardware expertise.
Conclusions
In summary, many new vehicles today come equipped with both Apple CarPlay and Android Auto compatibility. Automakers have increasingly adopted support for both smartphone mirroring platforms as consumer demand grows for seamless integration and connectivity in vehicles. While implementing two separate systems introduces logistical challenges, most manufacturers now recognize the benefits outweigh the difficulties.
Offering compatibility with both Apple and Android devices allows automakers to appeal to a wider customer base. Drivers appreciate being able to access their preferred apps, messages, maps, and music through their vehicle’s infotainment system regardless of their smartphone’s operating system. This flexibility provides a better overall user experience.
To maximize usability and consumer appeal, it is recommended that automakers strive for consistent feature implementation across both platforms. While the driver interfaces may differ between CarPlay and Auto, core functionality should enable equivalent experiences. Continuing to enhance integration and expand supported apps will further increase the value proposition of built-in smartphone connectivity.
References
No sources were cited in this article.