Does Android Auto sound better than Bluetooth?

Android Auto and Bluetooth are two popular ways to stream audio from your smartphone to your car’s speakers. Android Auto connects your phone to your car’s infotainment system via USB or wireless connectivity, allowing you to access music, navigation, and other apps on your car’s display. Bluetooth is a wireless technology that allows you to pair your phone with your car’s audio system and stream audio over the Bluetooth connection.

There has been some debate around whether Android Auto or Bluetooth provides better sound quality for music playback. Some claim the wired and wireless Android Auto connections allow for higher bitrates and better quality, while others argue the Bluetooth audio compression technologies have improved enough that there is little perceptible difference.

In this article, we will compare the sound quality of Android Auto vs Bluetooth audio playback. We will examine the technical differences between how each system transmits audio and evaluate whether one provides noticeably better audio quality over the other in real-world usage. Our goal is to determine if there is an audible difference in music playback between streaming over Android Auto vs Bluetooth.

How Android Auto Works

Android Auto allows you to display supported apps from your Android phone onto your car’s infotainment screen. To use Android Auto, you connect your Android smartphone to your car’s infotainment system via USB cable. This allows Android Auto to mirror select apps from your phone onto your car’s touchscreen display. The car’s speakers are used to play audio from the Android Auto interface [1].

With Android Auto, the audio playback is handled directly between your phone and the car stereo. The audio data is transmitted digitally over the USB connection to the car’s head unit and DAC for conversion and amplification. This allows higher quality audio playback compared to streaming over Bluetooth which relies on lossy compression [2].

How Bluetooth Audio Works

Bluetooth is a wireless technology that allows devices to connect and communicate over short distances. For streaming music in a car, your smartphone with Bluetooth capability will pair with the car’s audio system using Bluetooth wireless technology. This allows the phone to transmit audio files like music to the car stereo without needing wires or cables [1].

To send audio over Bluetooth, the smartphone compresses the audio file using a codec like SBC or AAC. This compressed audio data is then transmitted wirelessly via Bluetooth to the car’s audio system. The car stereo has a built-in Bluetooth receiver that gets the wireless signal and decodes it back into an audio signal that can be played through the car speakers [2]. Essentially, Bluetooth allows compressed wireless transmission of audio, while the car stereo decompresses it for listening.

Sound Quality Factors

There are several key factors that determine the sound quality differences between Android Auto and Bluetooth audio connections:

Bitrates

Android Auto generally has higher bitrates than Bluetooth audio. Bitrate refers to the amount of data transmitted per second for the audio file, and higher bitrates allow for better quality audio reproduction. Android Auto can support lossless quality audio files and bitrates up to 9,216 kbps, while the maximum bitrate for Bluetooth audio is 345 kbps [1].

Codecs

The audio codecs used also impact sound quality. Android Auto supports high quality codecs like LDAC and aptX HD that can transmit more data than the standard SBC codec used over basic Bluetooth connections. This allows Android Auto to preserve more detail and deliver better audio fidelity [2].

DACs

Since Android Auto connects directly via USB, the audio signal benefits from passing through the high-quality digital-to-analog converter (DAC) in the car stereo system rather than the lower quality DAC in most smartphones. This provides superior analog conversion and amplification, leading to better sound [3].

Audio Processing

The additional audio processing capabilities provided by the car’s stereo system, like equalization, spatialization, and active noise cancellation, can further enhance the listening experience with Android Auto.

Bitrate Differences

One of the key factors in sound quality between Android Auto and Bluetooth is the bitrate, or the amount of data transmitted per second while streaming audio. Android Auto typically uses a higher bitrate than Bluetooth.

Android Auto running over a USB cable has the potential for lossless CD-quality audio at 1411 kbps. However, most Android Auto systems use a bitrate of 320 kbps for compressed high-quality audio streaming.1 This is still significantly higher than the maximum bitrate for Bluetooth audio streaming, which is 345 kbps for the aptX HD codec.

Standard Bluetooth using SBC codec has a maximum bitrate of 328 kbps, while the more advanced aptX codec supports up to 352 kbps. In contrast, the higher 320 kbps bitrate used by Android Auto allows for better audio quality with wider frequency response and dynamic range.

The higher bitrate of Android Auto compared to Bluetooth enables lower compression and higher sampling rates, resulting in better reproduction of subtle details in the music. This leads to clearer treble, tighter bass, and an overall more accurate and premium sounding audio experience.2

Codec Differences

Android Auto supports the following audio codecs:

  • PCM (uncompressed) – This is the default audio codec used by Android Auto for music playback and calls. PCM provides CD-quality lossless audio.
  • AAC-LC – Android Auto is capable of streaming AAC-LC codec if the car’s head unit requests it, but PCM is more commonly used.

Bluetooth supports a wider variety of audio codecs including:

  • SBC – This is the mandatory Bluetooth audio codec that all devices must support. It provides bitrates up to 328 kbps.
  • AAC-LC – More advanced than SBC, this provides better quality audio at bitrates up to 328 kbps.
  • aptX/aptX HD – Proprietary codecs capable of bitrates up to 576kbps/576kbps and lower latency.
  • LDAC – Sony’s proprietary codec capable of bitrates up to 990kbps.

While Bluetooth supports higher bitrate codecs like aptX and LDAC, most reports indicate Android Auto’s uncompressed PCM still provides better audio quality and clarity. The digital-to-analog conversion and audio processing done by Android Auto also helps improve the listening experience.

DAC Quality Differences

One key difference between Android Auto and Bluetooth audio is the digital-to-analog converter (DAC) used. Android Auto uses the DAC built into the car’s infotainment system, while Bluetooth relies on the DAC inside the phone or streaming device. The DAC converts the digital audio data into an analog signal that can be amplified and played through the speakers.

Since Android Auto leverages the car’s DAC, it will provide audio quality on par with other wired sources like Aux or USB connections. The DAC quality can vary depending on the vehicle, but is often higher end in modern infotainment systems. Meanwhile, the DAC used for Bluetooth is dependent on the transmitting device. Some smartphones have excellent quality DACs, while others may be more basic. Bluetooth speakers and adapters also have a wide range of DACs built-in. So Bluetooth quality relies heavily on the hardware capabilities.

Audio Processing

Both Android Auto and Bluetooth streaming apply audio processing that can impact sound quality. Android Auto has a system called Bluetooth Audio Processing Quality which improves the audio quality of Bluetooth streaming by applying equalization, dynamics processing, and other audio effects.

Some key differences in audio processing between Android Auto and standard Bluetooth streaming include:

  • Android Auto applies tuning specifically optimized for in-car audio systems, while Bluetooth tuning is more generic.
  • Android Auto can process high-resolution audio up to 24-bit/96kHz, while Bluetooth is limited to standard quality.
  • Android Auto has features like automatic loudness compensation and dynamic range control tailored for noisy car environments.
  • Standard Bluetooth relies more on the basic processing built into the phone and car audio system.

Overall, Android Auto’s dedicated audio tuning gives it an advantage over basic Bluetooth streaming when it comes to audio quality. The processing is tailored to overcome road noise, enhance clarity, and take advantage of high-fidelity audio systems. According to users, the difference in processing quality is noticeable, with Android Auto sounding smoother and more balanced (ref)[https://www.reddit.com/r/AndroidAuto/comments/10590cd/anybody_noticed_difference_in_audio_quality_over/].

Real-World Experience

Many users on Reddit have compared the sound quality of Android Auto to regular Bluetooth connections. The consensus seems to be that Android Auto does provide better audio quality in most cases. One user said “It seems to me like it does sound better than just Bluetooth audio.”

Expert reviews have also compared the audio quality. This review noted that when Android Auto stopped working, just using Bluetooth led to notably worse audio quality. The review concluded that Android Auto wireless provides better sound than Bluetooth alone.

Overall, real-world tests show that Android Auto’s audio architecture, with its high-quality DACs and audio processing, delivers improved sound over basic Bluetooth streaming. While the codecs may be similar, additional factors like bitrate, hardware quality, and tuning make a difference. Users consistently report Android Auto sounding fuller, richer, and cleaner compared to Bluetooth alone.

Conclusions

When comparing sound quality between Android Auto and Bluetooth connections, there are a few key factors to consider:

  • Bitrate, which relates to how much data is available to transmit the audio signal
  • Codec type, such as AAC or SBC
  • DAC (digital to analog converter) quality in each device
  • Audio processing settings and capabilities on each device

In general, as long as bitrates are set at 320kbps or higher on both connections, Android Auto tends to provide slightly better sound quality due to the ability to leverage high quality DACs and custom audio tuning built into many car stereo head units designed for Android Auto. However, high end Bluetooth audio devices with aptX or LDAC codecs can achieve equivalent or better sound quality when compared to entry and mid-range Android Auto setups.

To achieve the optimal listening experience:

  • Make sure maximum audio quality settings are enabled in your streaming apps and on both Android Auto and Bluetooth devices.
  • Consider hardware upgrades like installing a stereo head unit optimized for Android Auto to utilize better integrated DACs and audio tuning capabilities.
  • Test different codecs and bitrate settings with your Bluetooth devices to determine if options like aptX or higher bitrates improve your experience.

Overall there is no universially superior option. Both Android Auto and Bluetooth are capable of excellent sound quality given the right combination of hardware and configuration.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *