What is one drawback of using lavalier mics?

Interference Issues

One of the main drawbacks of lavalier microphones is they can easily pick up interference noise from clothing rustling or the mic cable rubbing against clothing. As the mic is clipped to a shirt or lapel, any movement can generate audible rustling or friction sounds. This is a common complaint with lav mics, as noted in forums such as Reddit: “You should try taping to the clothing – the lav will make much less noise rubbing against skin than it does rubbing against clothing.” (Source)

The mic cable rubbing against clothing is another source of interference noise. Audio-Technica recommends using the “broadcast loop” or “newsman’s loop” technique to minimize cable noise by securing the cable in the mic clip or tie. Proper positioning of the mic and cable, close to the body and away from loose clothing, can also help avoid picking up unwanted rustling and friction sounds.

Limited Range

One drawback of lavalier microphones is their limited range compared to handheld microphones. Lavalier mics utilize a small condenser capsule to pick up sound, making them less sensitive and limiting their frequency response. As this Gearspace thread discusses, lav mics tend to have a fairly flat response but may roll off at the frequency extremes.

The limited sensitivity and frequency response of lavalier mics also makes them prone to poor performance if the wearer turns their head away. The mic may not pick up enough signal at a distance or off-axis. So lav mics work best when positioned close to the speaker’s mouth and require the speaker to remain facing the mic for optimal sound quality.

Placement Challenges

One drawback of lavalier microphones is finding the optimal placement position on clothing. According to Rode, “As a general rule, placing the mic capsule over the talent’s sternum will give you a nice balance of close proximity and natural sound…” (https://rode.com/en/about/news-info/lavalier-mounting-best-practices). However, the exact positioning depends on factors like clothing type and body type. What works for one person may not work for another.

Lavalier mics can also lead to visible or awkward placement. The mic capsule and wiring may be visible on camera if not properly hidden. Alternatively, the mic may rub against clothing and create noise if placed poorly. There is an art to finding the optimal lavalier mic position for each unique situation.

Multiple Mic Issues

Using multiple lavalier microphones in close proximity can lead to cross-talk and other interference issues. The sound from each lav mic can bleed into the others, resulting in muddled or distorted audio. This becomes increasingly problematic the more lav mics you use in a setup. As noted on the r/livesound subreddit, multi-lav setups require expertise in mixing and mic technique to isolate each source and prevent crosstalk.

According to discussions on ProSoundWeb forums, recording multiple lavalier mics simultaneously demands proper mic placement and gain staging. The sound engineer must perfectly balance levels to minimize bleed between sources. This complicates setup, especially for videographers and podcasters without audio mixing experience. In short, using multiple lav mics can quickly turn problematic without the right gear, expertise, and technique.

Appearance Concerns

One drawback of lavalier microphones is that they can raise appearance concerns. The small microphone and wiring needed to attach a lavalier mic can end up being visible during use. This can look awkward or distracting, especially for public speaking, broadcasts, or performances where aesthetics and appearance are important.

Lavalier mics clip onto clothing or attach around the neck, so the mic and thin cable running to the transmitter pack are often unavoidably visible. The small mic can end up seeming out of place or detracting from someone’s look if it is seen on camera or by an audience. It can also be distracting seeing presenters adjust or touch the mic during a talk.

There are techniques to try minimizing the appearance of lavalier mics, like carefully positioning them or using flesh-colored cables. But it takes extra effort compared to headworn mics where the mic capsule hides in the clothing. For contexts like newscasts or theater where polished, professional appearance is key, the visibility of lavalier mics can be a drawback to consider.

Setup Time

One potential drawback of lavalier microphones is that they can take more time to set up properly compared to other microphone options. Lav mics need to be clipped to the talent’s clothing and the wire run up to attach to a transmitter pack. This process of attaching and positioning the mic takes more time than simply handing a handheld microphone to the speaker.

Additionally, more time may be required to hide the lav mic wire and secure it in place so it doesn’t interfere with movement or make noise. The wire needs to be run neatly under clothing and secured with medical or athletic tape so it stays tucked away during filming. Hiding long mic wires can be tedious and add substantial setup time compared to other mics that don’t require wire management.1

Limited Applications

One drawback of lavalier mics is that they have limited applications compared to other microphone types. Lavalier mics tend to be less suitable for picking up loud or dynamic voices due to their small condenser capsules and proximity to the sound source. The capsules can become overloaded and distort when presented with loud volumes. Additionally, lavalier mics are attached closely to an individual’s body so they do not allow much room for expressive gesticulation or vocal projection without bumping into the mic. This makes lavalier mics not ideal for musical performances or speakers who rely on vocal dynamics and stage movement.

Durability Issues

One drawback of lavalier microphones is that they can have durability issues. The thin cables and connectors used with lavalier mics can be fragile and prone to damage (https://microphonegeeks.com/pro/lapel-microphone/). The small size also makes them easy to accidentally drop or bend, which can break internal components. Since lavalier mics are often clipped onto clothing or hidden in costumes, they are susceptible to being yanked, strained, or crushed during normal movement. This puts extra wear and tear on the cables and connections. According to audio experts, lavalier mics tend to have a shorter average lifespan than handheld or headset microphones due to their delicacy and vulnerability to abuse (https://www.soundguys.com/best-lavalier-microphones-77294/). Frequent replacement costs can add up over time. Care must be taken when using, storing, and transporting lavalier microphones to prevent damage that could render them unusable.

Cost Factor

One drawback of lavalier mics is that they tend to be more expensive than basic handheld microphones. The average consumer-grade lavalier mic costs between $20-100, while professional models can cost $200 or more (https://www.amazon.com/lavalier-microphone/s?k=lavalier+microphone). This higher cost comes from their smaller size and intended discreet use. Manufacturing miniaturized microphones requires more precision and higher-quality components, driving up the price.

Lavalier mics also frequently require additional equipment like wireless transmitters or recorders to connect and use them. These accessories add to the total system cost. For example, a wireless transmitter pack might cost $200-300 or more (https://www.bestbuy.com/site/searchpage.jsp?id=pcat17071&st=lavalier+microphone). The more features included like dual mic inputs, digital encryption, or longer ranges, the higher the price climbs. So lavalier setups end up costing significantly more than a basic wired microphone.

Expertise Needed

One drawback of lavalier microphones is that they require expertise to position and use properly. Unlike handheld or podium microphones, lav mics need to be clipped to clothing and positioned in just the right spot near the mouth to clearly pick up the speaker’s voice. Improper positioning can lead to muffled, inconsistent, or popping sounds. It takes practice to find the optimal placement for each speaker’s voice and body type.

In addition, using multiple wireless lavalier mics requires expertise to coordinate the frequencies and prevent interference or sound dropouts. The user needs knowledge of wireless systems to choose compatible frequencies and effectively manage several mics transmitting at once. Without this expertise, the lav miers may experience interference noise or cut out entirely during use.

Overall, while lavalier mics offer flexibility, their positioning and wireless coordination requires a level of expertise many novice users lack. Proper set up and use of lav mics relies heavily on the user’s experience and knowledge.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *